General Docket
US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Court of Appeals Docket #: 03-2069 Filed:
9/10/03
Nsuit: 3440 Civil Rights: Other
Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
Appeal from: District of South Carolina at Rock Hill
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Lower court information:
District: 0420-0 : CA-01-3409-0
Involved Judge: Dennis W. Shedd, District Judge
Court Reporter: Janet Woodward, Court Reporter Coordinator
Presiding Judge: Cameron McGowan Currie, District Judge
Date Filed: 8/20/01
Date order/judgment: 8/22/03
Date NOA filed: 8/25/03
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Fee status: Paid
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Prior cases:
None
Current cases:
None
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
1
03-2069 Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
DARLA KAYE WYNNE Herbert
E. Buhl, III
Plaintiff - Appellee FAX
803-252-2610
803-799-3767
[COR
NTC RET]
533
Harden Street
Columbia,
SC 29205
v.
TOWN OF GREAT FALLS, SOUTH Andrew
Frederick Lindemann
CAROLINA, an incorporated town FAX 803-806-8855
of the State of South Carolina, 803-806-8222
County of Chester [COR
LD NTC RET]
Defendant - Appellant DAVIDSON,
MORRISON & LINDEMANN,
PA
1611
Devonshire Road
P.
O. Box 8568
Columbia,
SC 29202-8568
HENRY CLAYTON STAMES, Mayor Andrew Frederick
Lindemann
Defendant - Appellant (See
above)
[COR
LD NTC RET]
JOHN BROOM, Councilman Andrew
Frederick Lindemann
Defendant - Appellant (See
above)
[COR
LD NTC RET]
HENRY STEVENSON, Councilman Andrew Frederick
Lindemann
Defendant - Appellant (See
above)
[COR
LD NTC RET]
BARBARA HILTON, Councilwoman Andrew Frederick
Lindemann
Defendant - Appellant (See
above)
[COR
LD NTC RET]
RAYMOND H. BAKER, Councilman Brian McDowell Gibbons
Defendant - Appellant 803-581-2211
[OBR]
HAMILTON,
HAMILTON, DELLENEY &
GIBBONS,
PA
128
Center Street
P.
O. Drawer 808
Chester,
SC 29706
Andrew
Frederick Lindemann
(See
above)
[COR
LD NTC RET]
JOE V. PENDERGRASS, Councilman
Defendant
-------------------------
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
2
03-2069 Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA Henry
Dargan McMaster, Attorney
Amicus Supporting General
Appellant 804-734-3693
[OBR]
Clyde
Havird Jones, Jr.,
Assistant
Attorney General
FAX
803-734-3677
803-734-3680
[COR
NTC GVT]
John
William McIntosh,
Assistant
Attorney General
803-734-3970
[OBR]
Robert
D. Cook
803-734-3970
[COR
NTC GVT]
OFFICE
OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
OF
SOUTH CAROLINA
Rembert
C. Dennis Office
Building
1000
Assembly Street
P.
O. Box 11549
Columbia,
SC 29211-1549
THE AMERICAN JEWISH CONGRESS Marc David Stern
Amicus Supporting FAX
212-861-7056
Appellee 212-360-1545
[COR
NTC RET]
AMERICAN
JEWISH CONGRESS
15
East 84th Street
New
York, NY 10028
AMERICANS UNITED FOR Ayesha
Naseem Khan
SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE FAX 202-466-2587
Amicus Supporting 202-466-3234
Appellee [COR
NTC RET]
518
C Street, NE
Washington,
DC 20002
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
3
03-2069 Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
9/9/03 Docketing
statement filed by Appellant [3851719-1] T/S
needed
[Y/N]: y T/S already on file?: y. [03-2069] ~
[3851719]
(saw)
9/10/03 Civil case docketed.
(saw)
9/10/03 Briefing order
filed. [03-2069] ~ [3851752] Appellant(s)
brief/joint
appendix due 10/20/03 for Raymond H. Baker, for
Barbara
Hilton, for Henry Stevenson, for John Broom, for
Henry
Clayton Stames, for Great Falls SC. (saw)
9/10/03 Docketing notice
issued. [03-2069] ~ [3851755] (saw)
9/17/03 Appearance form
filed by Herbert E. Buhl for Appellee Darla
Kaye
Wynne. [03-2069] (saw)
9/17/03 Negative disclosure
statement filed by Appellee Darla Kaye
Wynne [03-2069]
(saw)
9/24/03 Appearance form
filed by Andrew Frederick Lindemann for
Appellant
Raymond H. Baker, Appellant Barbara Hilton,
Appellant
Henry Stevenson, Appellant John Broom, Appellant
Henry
Clayton Stames, Appellant Great Falls SC. [03-2069]
(saw)
9/24/03 Negative disclosure
statement filed by Appellant Great
Falls
SC, Appellant Henry Clayton Stames, Appellant John
Broom,
Appellant Henry Stevenson, Appellant Barbara Hilton,
Appellant
Raymond H. Baker [03-2069] (saw)
9/30/03 ORDER FILED [3862552]
to extend time to file appellant(s)
brief/appendix
until 11/3/03 [3862552-1]. Appellant(s)
brief/joint
appendix now due 11/3/03 for Raymond H. Baker,
for
Barbara Hilton, for Henry Stevenson, for John Broom,
for
Henry Clayton Stames, for Great Falls SC. [03-2069] ~
[3862552]
(cdi)
10/16/03 Record on appeal filed. Pleadings:
Vols. 1,2 Transcript:
Vol.
3. . [03-2069] ~ [3871233] (saw)
10/16/03 ORDER FILED [3871329]
to extend time to file appellant(s)
brief
until 12/3/03 [3871329-1]. Appellant(s) brief/joint
appendix
now due 12/3/03 for Raymond H. Baker, for Barbara
Hilton,
for Henry Stevenson, for John Broom, for Henry
Clayton
Stames, for Great Falls SC [03-2069] ~ [3871329]
(saw)
10/17/03 Motion filed by to
file amicus brief. Amicus brief
tendered?(Y/N):
n. [3871834-1], to extend time to file
amicus
curiae brief until 11/24/03 [3871834-2]. [03-2069]
~
[3871834] (cdi)
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
4
03-2069 Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
10/17/03 ORDER FILED [3872100]
granting the State of SC's motion to
file
amicus brief [3871834-1]. Amicus brief due 12/10/03
for
State of SC, mooting motion to extend time to file am
br
[3871834-2] [03-2069] ~ [3872100] (cdi)
10/24/03 Appearance form filed
by Robert D. Cook for Amicus
Supporting
Appellant State of SC. [03-2069] (dsd)
10/27/03 Appearance form filed
by Clyde Havird Jones for Amicus
Supporting
Appellant State of SC. [03-2069] (dsd)
12/3/03 Joint appendix
filed by Appellant Great Falls SC. Copies of
apx:
6 # apx pages: 352[A Sufficient[Y/N]?: y. SEALED
vol.[Y/N]?:
n. 2-sided copying[Y/N]?: y. Method of filing
w/
court: HD Date of Service on parties: 12/3/03 by PM
[03-2069]
[3899086] (saw)
12/4/03 Brief filed by
Appellant Great Falls SC, Appellant Henry
Clayton
Stames, Appellant John Broom, Appellant Henry
Stevenson,
Appellant Barbara Hilton, Appellant Raymond H.
Baker. Copies
of brief: 9 # brf pages: 38.
Sufficient[Y/N]?:
y. SEALED?[Y/N]: n. Method of filing
w/
court: PM Date of Service on parties: 12/4/03 Type of
service
on parties: PM [03-2069] ~ [3899333] Appellee(s)
brief
due 1/6/04 for Darla Kaye Wynne. (saw)
12/9/03 Motion filed
by Appellant Great Falls SC for leave to file
brief
out of time as of 12/4/03 [3899096-1]. [03-2069] ~
[3899096]
(saw)
12/9/03 ORDER FILED [3899097]
granting motion to file brief out of
time
[3899096-1] as of 12/4/03 . [03-2069] ~ [3899097] (saw)
12/11/03 Amicus curiae brief
filed by Amicus Supporting Appellant
State
of SC Copies of brief: 9 # br pages: 34
Sufficient[Y/N]?:
n. n. Method of filing w/ court: PM
Date
of Service on parties: 12/11/03 Type of service on
parties:
PM [03-2069] ~ [3903265] (saw)
12/15/03 Brief made sufficient
by Appellant Great Falls SC, Appellant
Henry
Clayton Stames, Appellant John Broom, Appellant Henry
Stevenson,
Appellant Barbara Hilton, Appellant Raymond H.
Baker
to include certificate of compliance. Number of brf
pages:
38. [03-2069] ~ [3902102] (cdi)
12/16/03 Notice non-compliant
brief filed by Amicus Supporting
Appellant
State of SC. Why?: FRAP 32a(a)(5) - should be 14
point
font. format. [03-2069] ~ [3903268] Sufficient brief
due
on 12/29/03 for State of SC (saw)
12/18/03 Motion filed by Appellee
Darla Kaye Wynne to extend time to
file
appellee(s) brief until 1/26/04 [3904192-1].
[03-2069]
~ [3904192] (saw)
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
5
03-2069 Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
12/18/03 ORDER FILED [3904194]
granting motion to extend time to
file
e's br [3904192-1] Appellee(s) brief now due 1/26/04
for
Darla Kaye Wynne. [03-2069] ~ [3904194] (saw)
12/19/03 Brief made sufficient
by Amicus Supporting Appellant State
of
SC. Number of brf pages: 42. [03-2069] ~ [3907449] (saw)
1/26/04 Brief filed by
Appellee Darla Kaye Wynne. Copies of brief:
8
# brf pages: 45. Sufficient[Y/N]?: y. SEALED?[Y/N]: n.
Method
of filing w/ court: PM Date of Service on parties:
1/26/04 Type
of service on parties: PM [03-2069] ~
[3924271]
(saw)
2/4/04 Motion filed
by Potential Amicus Curiae American Jewish
Congress,
to file amicus brief. Amicus brief
tendered?(Y/N):
y. [3927981-1] [03-2069] ~ [3927981] (saw)
2/4/04 Response/answer
requested to motion to file amicus brief
[3927981-1] Response/answer
due 2/17/04 for Raymond H.
Baker,
for Barbara Hilton, for Henry Stevenson, for John
Broom,
for Joe V. Pendergrass, for Henry Clayton Stames,
for
Great Falls SC, for Darla Kaye Wynne. [03-2069] ~
[3928005]
(saw)
2/4/04 Amicus curiae
brief filed by Amicus Supporting Appellee
Americans
United Copies of brief: 8 # br pages: 36
Sufficient[Y/N]?:
y. n. Method of filing w/ court: PM
Date
of Service on parties: 2/4/04 Type of service on
parties:
PM [03-2069] ~ [3931177] (saw)
2/9/04 Motion filed
by Appellant Great Falls SC, Appellant Henry
Clayton
Stames, Appellant John Broom, Appellant Henry
Stevenson,
Appellant Barbara Hilton, Appellant Raymond H.
Baker
to extend time to file reply brief until 2/23/04
[3930357-1] [03-2069]
~ [3930357] (cdi)
2/9/04 ORDER FILED
[3930359] granting motion to ext time to file
reply
brf [3930357-1] until 2/23/04. Copies to all parties.
[03-2069]
~ [3930359] (cdi)
2/9/04 Consent
filed by Potential Amicus Curiae Americans United
to
file amicus brief. Amicus brief tendered?(Y/N): y.
[3931159-1] Party/parties
filing the amicus brief:
Americans
United for Separation of Church and State.
[03-2069]
(saw)
2/10/04 ORDER FILED [3931164]
granting consent to file amicus brief
[3931159-1]
Copies to all parties. [03-2069] ~ [3931164]
(saw)
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
6
03-2069 Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
2/12/04 Response/answer
filed [3932520-1] by Appellant Great Falls
SC,
Appellant Henry Clayton Stames, Appellant John Broom,
Appellant
Henry Stevenson, Appellant Barbara Hilton,
Appellant
Raymond H. Baker to motion to file amicus brief
[3927981-1] [03-2069]
~ [3932520] (saw)
2/12/04 Response/answer
filed [3932523-1] by Appellee Darla Kaye
Wynne
to motion to file amicus brief [3927981-1]
[03-2069]
~ [3932523] (saw)
2/12/04 ORDER FILED [3932551]
granting motion to file amicus brief
[3927981-1]
of American Jewish Congress. Copies to all
parties.
[03-2069] ~ [3932551] (saw)
2/12/04 Amicus curiae
brief filed by Amicus Supporting Appellee
American
Jewish Copies of brief: 9 # br pages: 29
Sufficient[Y/N]?:
y. n. Method of filing w/ court: order
Date
of Service on parties: 2/2/04 Type of service on
parties:
PM [03-2069] ~ [3932596] (saw)
2/12/04 Negative disclosure
statement filed by Amicus Supporting
Appellee
American Jewish [03-2069] (saw)
2/13/04 Case tentatively
calendared for oral argument Term: 5/04
Place:
Richmond. NOTIFY OF CONFLICT BY: 2/23/04. [00-6650,
02-1590,
02-1646, 02-1795, 02-2078, 02-4502, 02-4576,
02-4871,
02-7206, 02-7207, 02-7208, 02-7209, 03-10, 03-13,
03-25,
03-26, 03-27, 03-1093, 03-1102, 03-1414, 03-1433,
03-1505,
03-1555, 03-1796, 03-1556, 03-1578, 03-1588,
03-1600,
03-1659, 03-1668, 03-1761, 03-1779, 03-1962,
03-1788,
03-1918, 03-2357, 03-1811, 03-1840, 03-1860,
03-1867,
03-1879, 03-1896, 03-1911, 03-1912, 03-1937,
03-1948,
03-1975, 03-1977, 03-1985, 03-1991, 03-2012,
03-1995,
03-2011, 03-2017, 03-2020, 03-2026, 03-2051,
03-2054,
03-2059, 03-2060, 03-2061, 03-2062, 03-2064,
03-2069,
03-2070, 03-2076, 03-2078, 03-2081, 03-2082,
03-2085,
03-2100] ~ [3933877] (jc)
2/18/04 Appearance form
filed by Marc David Stern for Amicus
Supporting
Appellee American Jewish. [03-2069] (saw)
2/23/04 Appearance form
filed by Ayesha Naseem Khan for Amicus
Supporting
Appellee Americans United. [03-2069] (cdi)
2/23/04 Negative disclosure
statement filed by Amicus Supporting
Appellee
Americans United [03-2069] (cdi)
2/24/04 Reply brief filed
by Appellant Great Falls SC, Appellant
Henry
Clayton Stames, Appellant John Broom, Appellant Henry
Stevenson,
Appellant Barbara Hilton, Appellant Raymond H.
Baker. Copies
of brief: 8 # brf pages: 23.
Sufficient[Y/N]?:
y. SEALED[Y/N]?: n. Method of filing
w/
court: CD Date of Service on parties: 2/24/04 Type of
service
on parties: PM [03-2069] ~ [3939906] (saw)
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
7
03-2069 Wynne, et al v. Great Falls SC, et al
2/25/04 Motion filed
by Appellant Great Falls SC for leave to file
brief
out of time as of 2/24/04 [3939902-1]. [03-2069] ~
[3939902]
(saw)
2/25/04 ORDER FILED [3939905]
granting motion to file brief out of
time
[3939902-1] as of 2/24/04 . Copies to all parties.
[03-2069]
~ [3939905] (saw)
3/11/04 Case calendared
for oral argument. Case calendared for
oral
argument on: 5/6/04. [03-2069] ~ [3948589] (jle)
3/25/04 Appellant's brief,
Appellee's brief, Appellant's reply
brief,
and 3 Amicus briefs released to Lex Group. [03-2069]
(aww)
3/30/04 Appellant's Brief,
Appellee's Brief, Reply Brief and three
Amicus
Briefs returned by The Lex Group. [03-2069] (ce)
4/8/04 COURT ORDER
filed [3964369] continuing oral argument.
[3964369-1].
Argument continued until the week of 6/2/04
through
6/4/04. Copies to all parties. ~ [3964369]
[03-2069]
(dsd)
4/12/04 Case calendared
for oral argument. Case calendared for
oral
argument on: 6/2/04. [03-2069] ~ [3965201] (jc)
6/2/04 Oral argument
heard. Panel: Honorable Diana G. Motz,
Honorable
Robert B. King, Honorable David R. Hansen.
Courtroom
Deputy: SCC. [03-2069] (carr)
Docket as of July 22, 2004 0:21 am Page
8
|
